The tracks on Oddfellows can be easily divided into two categories – the pulverising rock tunes and the spookier, more subdued jazz-slash-lounge numbers. As exhilarating as songs like “South Paw” and the stomping title track are, Oddfellows’s quieter moments have more personality. Brain-damaged ballad “I.O.U.” genuinely tugs at the heartstrings, whilst “Rise Up Dirty Waters” and “I Can Almost See Them” whisk the listener away to that same eerie Twin Peaks place Patton conjured on Mr. Bungle’s second album, Disco Volante.
Despite the frequent changes in genre and volume, Oddfellows sustains a palpable identity throughout. It doesn’t have the gnash of Tomahawk’s eponymous debut, the polish of Mit Gas, or the hypnosis of Anonymous, but it makes up for that with its diversity and unsettling atmosphere.
All in all, Oddfellows is a thrilling and colourful addition to Tomahawk’s discography, even if it doesn’t quite reach the heights of their best work.
4/5